Numbered bullets added ...
1) the gallina india you bought, I suppose it was not bought from a poor salvadorean peasant, was it?
2) It was raised free-range either in the US or maybe in Salvador (but you have to add the price of transportation), on purpose, and I am pretty sure that you paid more, by pound, than for a battery chicken, didn't you?
3) Well, however excellent the broth was, it still seems bizarre to my eyes to pay more per pound (unless I am mistaken) for great broth and unedible meat than for meat.
4) Carcasses and scraps would make much cheaper and almost as good broth, wouldn't they?
1) I can only speculate, but tempering what I observed regarding anatomical differences against the hypothetical cost of shipping something from el salvador, I suspect (a) it was not flown in fresh from el salvador, (b) it definitely was very athletic and probably free range prior to slaughter, (c) it was VERY fresh - fresher than the pile of pale, bloated, watery and exudative purdues laying next to it, and (d) it was probably from a variety bred specifically for laying eggs and making soup rather than for roasting/frying ... which is a perfectly viable breeding strategy.
2) If I recall, the bird I grabbed was roughly 3.1 lbs, and $1.56 USD/lb ... which, given it's notably superior broth (in both flavor and quantity) is perfectly competitive with the $0.99 USD/lb laying next to it. Given the pleasure I had from learning something new, plus the fact that it made more & better tasting broth, I think the $1.74 USD difference in total cost was well worth it. The $1.56 is also very competitive with other premium varieties of poultry I've seen on sale, so it's economically viable for it's niche.
3) Reread my post. I said the meat was only inedible after the initial roasting ... it became edible after prolonged simmering, albeit somewhat tough and washed out (as most poultry tends to get when simmered that long).
4) Yes, but the whole point of my grabbing the gallina india, rather than the usual battery chicken, was to learn the nuances of something new and different. Mission accomplished.
Anyway, picking up the story where I left off ...
After letting the broth chill overnight in the fridge, I scooped away the solidified traces of fat (not very much). The both was well gelled and flavorful, and even though I'd skipped doing a remoulage, the yeild was fairly impressive (roughly 1qt/lb poultry). Anyway, to finish the soup, I brought it back to a simmer. Since I didn't have a driving need for alternate use for the boiled meat, I wound up adding it back to the soup (if I were having guests over I probably would have instead obtained, deboned and diced in some fresh chicken thigh meat during the last few minutes of the simmer, or stirred in a few beaten eggs at the last second). As for starch a veg - a traditional hispanic finish would have been to add something like diced yuca, some chunks of corn on the cob, and perhaps some carrot or chayote, but not having any of those handy I added orzo pasta, followed several minutes later with large bias dice of 2 medium zucchini, and then some cilantro at the last minute. Came out great.