Ecce and Old Earth (Cadwal Chronicles - 2)
Perhaps a bit of a letdown after the first book (which I had found to be quite good), but not nearly as bad as a fair number of highly negative reviews had suggested. Having said that, I would agree that neither the climax, which is a long time coming, nor the denouement, are really up there with Vance at his best.
While the book spends some time recounting the next round of adventures of Araminta Station's protagonist, Glawen Clattuc, the story primarily focuses on Glawen's love interest, Wayness Tamm, as she tries to unravel the mystery of what happened to the Cadwal Charter. It's worth your time if for no other reason than the oddness of Vance's efforts to provide a feminine version of his prototypical male protagonist.
Have you read this book? Click here to rate it!
Jack Vance - Ecce and Old Earth - 6
Here you can post book reviews for the IBDoF. Share your thoughts with the world and tell us what you think of the latest book you've read.
[NOTE: to create a properly linked book review thread here in TCC, please click on the "Review this Book" link from the applicable detailed book view in the IBDoF database - it will automatically generate a linked review here.
[NOTE: to create a properly linked book review thread here in TCC, please click on the "Review this Book" link from the applicable detailed book view in the IBDoF database - it will automatically generate a linked review here.
Moderators: clong, Mr. Titanic
Return to “The Critic's Corner”
Jump to
- Community Message Board
- ↳ The Reading Room
- ↳ IBDoF Reading Group
- ↳ Announcements on Books, Authors & Conventions
- ↳ The Margins
- ↳ The Appendix
- ↳ The Tap Room
- ↳ Ask The Oracle
- ↳ Forum Feedback & Suggestions
- IBDoF Member Services
- ↳ The Critic's Corner
- ↳ Announcements by the Webmaster
- ↳ IBDoF Site & Database Discussion
- Internet Book List
- ↳ IBList General Discussion
- ↳ IBList Book of the Week
- ↳ IBList Announcements
- ↳ IBList Suggestions
- Official Author Discussion Fora (Moderated)
- ↳ Charles Pellegrino
- ↳ David B. Coe
- ↳ Elizabeth Bear
- ↳ Heather Gladney
- ↳ Jack McDevitt
- ↳ John Dalmas
- ↳ L. E. Modesitt
- ↳ Lois McMaster Bujold
- ↳ Sharon Lee and Steve Miller
- Unofficial Author Discussion Fora
- ↳ Edgar Allan Poe
- ↳ Frank Herbert
- ↳ J.K. Rowling
- ↳ J.R.R. Tolkien
- ↳ Jane Lindskold
- ↳ Robert A. Heinlein
- ↳ Robert Jordan
- ↳ Stephen King
- ↳ William Shakespeare
- ↳ Winston Graham
- ↳ The DOLDRUMS
- ↳ Cordwainer Smith
- ↳ David & Leigh Eddings
- ↳ David Gemmell
- ↳ Douglas Adams
- ↳ H.P. Lovecraft
- ↳ Isaac Asimov
- ↳ Orson Scott Card
- ↳ Philip Pullman
- ↳ Robert E. Howard
- ↳ Stephen R. Donaldson
- ↳ Terry Goodkind
- ↳ Terry Pratchett
- ↳ Ursula K. LeGuin
- ↳ {Genre} Dragonflight & Dragonlance
- ↳ {Genre} Distributed Computing
- ↳ {Genre} Westerns
- Miscellaneous Genres
- ↳ Comics: Graphic Fiction & Anime
- ↳ Romance Books
- ↳ Star Trek & Star Wars
- The Amateur's Alcove
- ↳ L. E. Modesitt -> RPG
- ↳ Poetry, Lyrics & Ancient Classics
- ↳ The Quill & Fountain