Harlan Jay Ellison - Again, Dangerous Visions - 6
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 5:10 am
Again, Dangerous Visions
The original Dangerous Visions anthology contained quite a few very strong stories, but is probably best known more as a sort of manifesto for speculative fiction that would push its readers and ignore boundaries than for its specific contents.
This follow-up anthology is a long, long book featuring stories from an entirely different set of authors. There are a few good stories, but the general level is not up to that of the first book, and there are a few stories the inclusion of which left me completely baffled. Ellison's preface and introductions, which I had enjoyed in the original anthology, grew increasingly irritating here, and I gave up on reading them about halfway through.
My favorite stories were all by women authors: Joanna Russ' superb "When It Changed" is perhaps the most effective feminist scifi I have ever read; the entries from Kate Wilhelm, James Tiptree, Jr, and Ursula Le Guin were also very strong. I can admire the ambition behind entries from Piers Anthony and Richard Lupoff, even if neither was completely successful.
Have you read this book? Click here to rate it!
The original Dangerous Visions anthology contained quite a few very strong stories, but is probably best known more as a sort of manifesto for speculative fiction that would push its readers and ignore boundaries than for its specific contents.
This follow-up anthology is a long, long book featuring stories from an entirely different set of authors. There are a few good stories, but the general level is not up to that of the first book, and there are a few stories the inclusion of which left me completely baffled. Ellison's preface and introductions, which I had enjoyed in the original anthology, grew increasingly irritating here, and I gave up on reading them about halfway through.
My favorite stories were all by women authors: Joanna Russ' superb "When It Changed" is perhaps the most effective feminist scifi I have ever read; the entries from Kate Wilhelm, James Tiptree, Jr, and Ursula Le Guin were also very strong. I can admire the ambition behind entries from Piers Anthony and Richard Lupoff, even if neither was completely successful.
Have you read this book? Click here to rate it!